Why Our Children Can't Read and What We Can Do About It: A Scientific Revolution in Reading - Book reviews of Why Our Children Can't Read and What We Can Do About It: A Scientific Revolution in Reading

'Why Our Children Can't Read and What We Can Do About It: A Scientific Revolution in Reading' book reviews

Review for'Why Our Children Can't Read and What We Can Do About It: A Scientific Revolution in Reading'

"Why Our Children Can't Read and What We Can Do About It: A Scientific Revolution in Reading" by Diane McGuinness is a seminal work that delves into the complexities of reading instruction and literacy development. McGuinness, a cognitive psychologist and expert in reading research, presents a compelling argument for why traditional methods of teaching reading are insufficient and often detrimental to children's literacy development. Her book is both a critique of the current educational system and a guide for implementing scientifically-based reading instruction.

McGuinness begins by outlining the scope of the reading crisis in the United States, where a significant percentage of children struggle with reading despite years of schooling. She meticulously dissects the historical and pedagogical reasons behind this widespread issue, pointing out that many reading programs are based on outdated theories and lack empirical support. According to McGuinness, the phonics versus whole language debate has overshadowed the need for a more nuanced understanding of how children learn to read.

One of the most striking aspects of the book is McGuinness's ability to translate complex scientific research into accessible language. She explains the cognitive processes involved in reading, emphasizing the importance of phonemic awareness and the alphabetic principle. The author argues that effective reading instruction must be rooted in these foundational skills, which are often neglected in favor of more superficial teaching methods. McGuinness also highlights the role of working memory and linguistic awareness in reading proficiency, offering a comprehensive framework for understanding how children become literate.

McGuinness doesn't just diagnose the problem; she offers practical solutions grounded in scientific research. She advocates for a structured, systematic approach to reading instruction that prioritizes phonemic awareness and explicit teaching of the alphabetic code. The book provides detailed guidelines for educators and parents, including specific exercises and activities to enhance children's reading skills. These recommendations are backed by rigorous studies and real-world examples, making them both credible and actionable.

One of the book's strengths is its critical examination of popular reading programs and educational policies. McGuinness is unafraid to challenge the status quo, calling out ineffective practices and advocating for evidence-based reforms. This bold stance is likely to resonate with educators and parents frustrated by the limitations of current reading instruction methods. However, some readers may find her critique somewhat harsh, particularly those who have invested time and resources into traditional teaching methods.

Overall, "Why Our Children Can't Read and What We Can Do About It" is a thought-provoking and invaluable resource for anyone involved in literacy education. McGuinness's blend of scientific rigor and practical advice makes it a must-read for educators, parents, and policymakers committed to improving children's reading outcomes. The book not only identifies the root causes of the reading crisis but also offers a clear, research-based roadmap for achieving literacy for all children. While some of her views may be contentious, McGuinness's commitment to evidence-based practice provides a much-needed perspective in the ongoing debate over reading instruction.

Similar BooksMore