Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art - Book reviews of Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art

'Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art' book reviews

Review for'Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art'

Scott McCloud's "Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art" is a groundbreaking exploration into the world of comics that transcends the mere appreciation of the medium to delve into its underlying mechanics and its potential as an art form. Originally published in 1993, this seminal work has since become a cornerstone in the study of visual storytelling, offering insights that are as valuable to seasoned artists and writers as they are to casual enthusiasts of the genre.

One of the most striking aspects of "Understanding Comics" is its innovative format. McCloud uses the medium of comics to explain the theory and practice of comics, resulting in a meta-narrative that is both engaging and instructive. The book is essentially a comic about comics, featuring McCloud himself as the narrator who guides readers through a labyrinthine exploration of visual art, storytelling, and the unique combination of the two that defines the comic book medium.

McCloud begins by tackling the very definition of comics, offering a broad and inclusive characterization that encompasses everything from traditional superhero stories to avant-garde graphic novels. He then systematically deconstructs the elements that make up this diverse medium, including panels, lines, colors, and transitions. Each aspect is examined in meticulous detail, often accompanied by illustrative examples that make complex concepts easier to grasp.

One of the book’s most compelling chapters is the one on "closure," the mental process by which readers fill in gaps between panels. McCloud argues that this interactive component is what sets comics apart from other forms of visual storytelling, such as film or animation. This chapter alone is worth the price of admission, as it provides a profound understanding of how comics engage the reader’s imagination to create a dynamic narrative experience.

Another highlight is McCloud’s exploration of the "six steps" of artistic creation, which include idea/purpose, form, idiom, structure, craft, and surface. This framework not only applies to comics but can also be extended to other forms of art, making the book valuable for anyone interested in creative processes. McCloud’s lucid explanations and thoughtful insights make these abstract concepts accessible, offering readers practical tools to better understand and create their own works.

Moreover, "Understanding Comics" is notable for its inclusivity and respect for the medium's diversity. McCloud does not privilege one style or genre over another; instead, he celebrates the vast array of possibilities that comics offer. Whether discussing the intricate line work of underground comix or the bold, dynamic action of mainstream superhero books, McCloud treats each with equal seriousness and respect.

However, the book is not without its minor flaws. At times, McCloud’s enthusiasm can lead to overly dense passages that may require multiple readings to fully comprehend. Additionally, while the book is visually engaging, some readers might find the heavy reliance on examples from American and European comics to be somewhat limiting, wishing for a broader inclusion of global traditions.

In conclusion, Scott McCloud's "Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art" is an essential read for anyone interested in the medium of comics, whether they are creators, critics, or fans. Its blend of insightful analysis, historical perspective, and practical advice makes it a timeless resource that continues to inspire and educate more than two decades after its initial publication. McCloud’s passion for the art form is evident on every page, making "Understanding Comics" not just a book about comics, but a celebration of what they can achieve.

Similar BooksMore