Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA - Book reviews of Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA

'Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA' book reviews

Review for'Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA'

Tim Weiner’s “Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA” offers a meticulously researched and deeply critical examination of the Central Intelligence Agency from its inception in 1947 to the early 21st century. Weiner, an experienced journalist with The New York Times and a Pulitzer Prize winner, leverages his investigative prowess to present a narrative that is both compelling and alarming. The title itself, “Legacy of Ashes,” sets the tone for the book, suggesting a history marked by failures and missteps.

One of the book’s greatest strengths is Weiner’s use of declassified documents and firsthand accounts from former CIA officers and officials. This wealth of primary sources lends the work an air of authenticity and authority. Weiner doesn’t just rely on public records; he digs deep into the archives, uncovering details that were previously hidden from the public eye. The result is a comprehensive and often disturbing portrayal of the agency’s operations, decisions, and the consequences thereof.

Weiner’s narrative is unflinching in its criticism. He documents a series of blunders and ethical lapses that have plagued the CIA throughout its history. From the failed attempts to overthrow foreign governments, such as the Bay of Pigs invasion in Cuba, to the mishandling of intelligence that led to the 9/11 attacks, Weiner paints a picture of an organization that has often been its own worst enemy. He argues that the agency's penchant for covert action and paramilitary operations has frequently led to disastrous outcomes, both for the United States and for the countries involved.

Despite its critical tone, “Legacy of Ashes” is not merely a litany of failures. Weiner also provides context for the decisions made by the CIA, exploring the political and cultural environment in which these choices were made. He acknowledges the immense challenges faced by the agency, including the complex nature of global politics and the inherent difficulties of intelligence work. However, he remains steadfast in his conclusion that the agency's track record is one of repeated miscalculations and systemic issues.

The book is structured chronologically, which helps readers follow the evolution of the CIA over the decades. This approach also allows Weiner to highlight recurring themes and issues, such as the agency’s often fraught relationship with U.S. presidents and its struggles with bureaucratic infighting. The chronological structure makes the book accessible, even to readers who may not be familiar with the intricacies of intelligence work.

Weiner’s writing is clear and engaging, making “Legacy of Ashes” a surprisingly readable account, given the complexity of its subject matter. He has a knack for storytelling, weaving together facts and anecdotes in a way that keeps readers engaged from start to finish. However, the book’s critical stance may not sit well with everyone, particularly those who view the CIA in a more favorable light. Weiner’s conclusions are stark and unambiguous, and some readers may find his perspective overly negative.

In conclusion, “Legacy of Ashes: The History of the CIA” is a compelling and thought-provoking read that offers a critical perspective on one of the world’s most secretive organizations. Tim Weiner’s extensive research and engaging writing make this book a valuable resource for anyone interested in the history of intelligence and the complex interplay of power, politics, and secrecy. While its critical tone may be controversial, it provides a necessary counterbalance to more hagiographic accounts of the CIA’s history, encouraging readers to question and reconsider the agency’s legacy.

Similar BooksMore